+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 16 to 29 of 29

Thread: 2009, the start of the decline for private trackers?

  1. #16

    Join Date
    15.03.12
    Location
    Nowhere
    P2P Client
    utorrent
    Posts
    451
    Activity Longevity
    0/20 15/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 ssssss451
    I really miss the gaming sites. BCG / BG / UG.

    GGN is the only one left.
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  2. #17
    Member illusive's Avatar
    Join Date
    24.10.10
    P2P Client
    What ?! That's Private!
    Posts
    505
    Activity Longevity
    3/20 16/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 ssssss505
    Quote Originally Posted by Jordan View Post
    I really miss the gaming sites. BCG / BG / UG.

    GGN is the only one left.
    UG exists in the shadow http://retrowith.in/

    Other gaming trackers also there

    playbits.org
    bitgamer.ch
    ultimategamer.club
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  3. Who Said Thanks:

    Jordan (21.05.18)

  4. #18
    Moderator anon's Avatar
    Join Date
    01.02.08
    Posts
    39,385
    Activity Longevity
    11/20 19/20
    Today Posts
    4/5 ssss39385
    Quote Originally Posted by Jordan View Post
    I really miss the gaming sites. BCG / BG / UG.

    GGN is the only one left.
    There's also UGC and PleasureDome!

    I really miss U-G's invite forum
    "I just remembered something that happened a long time ago."
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  5. #19

    Join Date
    15.03.12
    Location
    Nowhere
    P2P Client
    utorrent
    Posts
    451
    Activity Longevity
    0/20 15/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 ssssss451
    Quote Originally Posted by illusive View Post
    UG exists in the shadow http://retrowith.in/

    Other gaming trackers also there

    playbits.org
    bitgamer.ch
    ultimategamer.club
    Thanks for the info. Where can I get invites for UGC and Retro? I tried the PTP forums but they don't have it.
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  6. #20
    H265's Avatar
    Join Date
    26.05.13
    Location
    Tengoku
    P2P Client
    ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
    Posts
    422
    Activity Longevity
    3/20 13/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 ssssss422
    Quote Originally Posted by Jordan View Post
    Thanks for the info. Where can I get invites for UGC and Retro? I tried the PTP forums but they don't have it.
    A friend told me ugc recruits on waffles but i'm not sure as i'm not a member there. I've seen users offer retrowithin on invite forums like ti.org
    Last edited by Instab; 22.05.18 at 21:07. Reason: dupe
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  7. #21

    Join Date
    18.06.10
    Posts
    54
    Activity Longevity
    0/20 17/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 sssssss54
    my guess is it's due to age, less time and less interest - the site operators are getting older and have more rl responsibilities and less free time plus lose interest in the project over time - you can't expect people to be interested in the same thing forever or be as passionate about it as in the beginning. to outsiders it might seem websites run on autopilot - but it`s really not.

    and i can totally understand the rationale that the siteops rather quit & wipe everything than hand over years of hard work to some unkown random person - it`s a responsibility to the community to protect sensitive user data from potentially malicious strangers.

    oh and the users have less interest, too - it`s a worldwide phenomenon - nowadays there are affordable & comfortable official alternatives to filesharing and people embrace them and those subscription services contributed to the overall decline in filesharing.

    personally i`m really sad about the demise of underground-gamer & it`s sister site bitgamer and asiandvdclub. not that i downloaded a ton from there or was an active forum or irc poster - i really loved the spirit of the community and the passion. in adcs & ugs case such huge archives are lost forever and can`t ever be rebuild or recovered. the younger gen doesn`t care and the older gen doesn`t, too, because they don`t have so much time left anymore anyway.

    people always bring up that hydra proverb with filesharing sites "for every head cut off, two more heads grow back" - but sadly it`s never the case. there have been no decent alternatives or spiritual successors - and probably never will be. eveyt time some copycats emerge for a brief time to grab some user info but they quickly vanish into obscurity.

    only recently after doing a lot of research i was able to find out how the cms (content-management-system) of those trackers was called. i forgot it already. it´s called "TBSource". i always loved how trackers that deployed it looked so clean and minimalist - really pleasant to the eyes - and how fast and easy it was to browse and navigate - really an efficient user experience.

    i keep reading that "gazelle / ocelot" from what.cd is considered by many the "gold standard" of tracker cms. i have to disagree, it looks really ugly and is super inefficient and full of javascript.
    only that pos "unit3d" is worse, such a chore to navigate and even with just a few tabs open brings most cpus down to their knees. and it's so ugly with it's excessively huge fonts optimized for mobile, like who torrents on tablets and smartphones?

    i miss the pre-smartphone/tablet era web 1.0. now the internet is so commercialized / polypolized with eveything in the hands of a few.
    in the late 90s / early 2000s i really thought the web would be split between many small players.
    i really hate how the general public is ok with giving up their privacy and all their actions being monitored by coporations & goverments 24-7.
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  8. Who Said Thanks:

    Rupel89yt (04.09.22) , anon (03.09.22)

  9. #22
    Advanced User Blocker's Avatar
    Join Date
    11.03.09
    Location
    The Pirate Bay
    P2P Client
    VEM
    Posts
    1,606
    Activity Longevity
    5/20 18/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 sssss1606
    Quote Originally Posted by slikrapid View Post
    some possible explanations:
    - periods of increased law enforcement activity
    - change of generations of p2p users
    - saturation over the years
    - lack of new ideas and ways to reinvent filesharing
    - other available options, like streaming

    seems like most of these trackers have been successfully replaced by new ones (p2p music trackers) or older ones that already had a sizable community (general trackers, p2p music trackers)

    the exception may be dedicated scene music trackers which were active during the last 5-10 years but afaik never recovered since
    I think the main reason will be streaming, every year it is more accesible for everyone ,it is more practical than download movies , music and TV shows , people always look for easier ways to get things. Even music videos are now very easy to find them on youtube.
    Last edited by Blocker; 03.09.22 at 21:08.
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  10. #23
    Moderator anon's Avatar
    Join Date
    01.02.08
    Posts
    39,385
    Activity Longevity
    11/20 19/20
    Today Posts
    4/5 ssss39385
    Quote Originally Posted by hazz030 View Post
    to outsiders it might seem websites run on autopilot - but it`s really not.

    it`s a responsibility to the community to protect sensitive user data from potentially malicious strangers.
    I'm glad someone pointed this out. Chain of trust in particular is a universally sensitive issue. Trusting your staff doesn't just mean picking someone capable for the job - they must also never turn on you for whatever reason, relay confidential information to others, or get compromised in any way. The only way three people can keep a secret, etc. The 2010 hostile takeovers of PTP and BTN, 2011 What.cd donation scandal and 2019 32pag.es breach are just a few (and very prominent) examples of things going wrong.

    personally i`m really sad about the demise of underground-gamer & it`s sister site bitgamer and asiandvdclub. not that i downloaded a ton from there or was an active forum or irc poster - i really loved the spirit of the community and the passion. in adcs & ugs case such huge archives are lost forever and can`t ever be rebuild or recovered. the younger gen doesn`t care and the older gen doesn`t, too, because they don`t have so much time left anymore anyway.
    RetroWith.in is supposed to be U-G's successor, though I'm not a member and have no idea what they're like. Romulation.net and Archive.org are decent substitutes. eMule can also be surprisingly good for abandonware games, depending on which generation and platform you're interested on. Of course, what U-G had going for it was everything being centralized in a single place, following upload rules and rarely going unseeded, plus a community of people who were very enthusiastic about retro games but would often downvote your forum posts without explanation. The ridiculousness of them shutting down over a takedown claim for FIFA 99 is a strong argument in favor of copyright reform, but it is what it is.

    All I know about ADC is that there was a revival attempt which falsely claimed to be official, and might have also been a cash grab. AvistaZ and KG are the oft-quoted alternatives, but good luck joining the latter.

    nowadays there are affordable & comfortable official alternatives to filesharing

    people always bring up that hydra proverb with filesharing sites "for every head cut off, two more heads grow back" - but sadly it`s never the case.
    The hydra was definitely a thing back in the day, but the existence of attractive legal alternatives as you and Blocker mentioned, and increasing barriers to entry when it comes to starting and running a secure tracker, have made it much more difficult for its heads to grow back.

    i keep reading that "gazelle / ocelot" from what.cd is considered by many the "gold standard" of tracker cms.
    I don't think there's a gold standard, it depends on what you want to do. Gazelle actually has a good and responsive design (which shows the most in the Kuro, Proton and Anorex stylesheets), but takes work to morph from a music tracker into something else, logs an insane amount of data, and has at least three different active forks. In turn, the TB source is probably better suited for general trackers, but requires extensive patching if you want to run it efficiently on a modern setup and don't like SQL injections or RCE exploits.

    Small history lesson: the "TB" stands for TorrentBits, which wasn't the first private tracker, but codified the concept as we know it today. After its closure, some of its former staff went on to found TorrentBytes, which referenced this in its site banner for a few years. Neither has any relation to the long-defunct TorrentBits.ro. Also, see https://www.sb-innovation.de/showthread.php?t=14163.

    i miss the pre-smartphone/tablet era web 1.0.
    People's mentality was different, but there was less to do and access was slow and expensive. Anyway, that was then and this is now.
    "I just remembered something that happened a long time ago."
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  11. Who Said Thanks:

    Schlagseite (08.09.22) , hazz030 (04.09.22) , Rupel89yt (04.09.22) , Blocker (04.09.22)

  12. #24
    Member mammamia11's Avatar
    Join Date
    29.02.08
    Location
    street
    P2P Client
    vuze
    Posts
    326
    Activity Longevity
    3/20 19/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 ssssss326
    This happend with all swedish trackers, its rare/imposible to find or join one today started from 2009 indeed when they started trail first with public trackers like Thepiratebay
    When you get to hell, tell em' Duke sent ya
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  13. Who Said Thanks:

    anon (10.09.22)

  14. #25
    Moderator anon's Avatar
    Join Date
    01.02.08
    Posts
    39,385
    Activity Longevity
    11/20 19/20
    Today Posts
    4/5 ssss39385
    I remember how valuable SweDVDR was to traders, as it had great content plus high rarity, and accounts were only usable from Scandinavian IPs. TTi hosted a large periphery demographic of members from outside that region, since it was a comfy general tracker with a nice seed hour system.
    "I just remembered something that happened a long time ago."
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  15. #26
    Advanced User Blocker's Avatar
    Join Date
    11.03.09
    Location
    The Pirate Bay
    P2P Client
    VEM
    Posts
    1,606
    Activity Longevity
    5/20 18/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 sssss1606
    Quote Originally Posted by anon View Post
    I remember how valuable SweDVDR was to traders, as it had great content plus high rarity, and accounts were only usable from Scandinavian IPs. TTi hosted a large periphery demographic of members from outside that region, since it was a comfy general tracker with a nice seed hour system.
    I had a TTi account , it was good tracker . Also what about pretimes ? are people still caring about them?
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  16. Who Said Thanks:

    anon (11.09.22)

  17. #27
    Moderator anon's Avatar
    Join Date
    01.02.08
    Posts
    39,385
    Activity Longevity
    11/20 19/20
    Today Posts
    4/5 ssss39385
    Quote Originally Posted by Blocker View Post
    what about pretimes ? are people still caring about them?
    It's been a long time since I last saw anyone do so. In hindsight, the only thing pretimes were good for was determining the solidity of a tracker's scene access (very important back then as the P2P release group boom was only beginning to begin), or whether they had such access at all. Not that this stopped people from using them as a reason to request "better" invites, even though the differences were of a few minutes at worst, and typically less than one

    Don't forget packs, and of course, the community!
    "I just remembered something that happened a long time ago."
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  18. Who Said Thanks:

    Blocker (19.09.22)

  19. #28

    Join Date
    16.01.10
    Location
    Mars
    P2P Client
    Nokia 6310
    Posts
    61
    Activity Longevity
    0/20 17/20
    Today Posts
    0/5 sssssss61
    Quote Originally Posted by anon View Post
    Every now and then (and particularly, whenever I have to close review threads) I think about this. It seems that from 2009 onwards, we have had a ton of prominent trackers close, with few springing up to take their place. It started with TTi and those Nordic sites, which chose to either shut down or restrict operations when Sweden became a less friendly place for filesharing, and as the end of that year approached, we saw ScT, UK-T and FTWR disappear, almost within the same month.

    Ever since, at least a couple of major players have fallen every year, the latest examples being GFT, SCC, What.cd and BCG. Of course, it's not like no tracker had ever shut down before (OiNK, EliteTorrents, SuprNova), but it happened much less often, and with alternatives always appearing to fill the void. Now it's the opposite.

    Let's see if you remember these names:
    • ScT / SceneTorrents
    • SCC / SceneAccess
    • UK-T
    • FTWR / Follow The White Rabbit
    • What.cd
    • GFT / GeForces Tracker
    • FTN / FeedTheNet
    • TorrentVault
    • TorrentShack
    • ScL / SceneLife
    • BCG / Blackcats Games
    • BitGamer, Underground-Gamer
    • FreshOn.TV (a.k.a. TV.TORRENTS.RO)
    • TvTorrents.com
    • Cheggit
    • PureTNA
    • Filepost, FileMP3, Fileporn
    • SuperTorrents, STMusic
    • SoftMP3
    • SweDVDR
    • SceneSound, CareStreet
    • TranceRoute
    • TorrentIt
    • PackMeIn
    • elektROnik
    • SyncTheBits
    • Pimp my Mobile

    Am I imagining things, or did trackers really close faster than they can be replaced? In the latter case, why?
    ScT, FTWR, What.cd, Underground-Gamer, syncthebits,

    these were the sites i really wanted to get in... never had the chance, and now i never would have
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

  20. #29
    Moderator anon's Avatar
    Join Date
    01.02.08
    Posts
    39,385
    Activity Longevity
    11/20 19/20
    Today Posts
    4/5 ssss39385
    ScT was the pinnacle of scene trackers. Very low pretimes, excellent speeds, great retention (partly in the form of exclusive packs), and cheating was very easy Sure, it's not like you'd die if you didn't get in (which expectedly wasn't trivial; invites only awarded via donation plus a user cap of 20,000 slots). There was no shortage of alternatives carrying the same content, just like there isn't now. But they had everything in one place, and their good reputation was very well-earned.

    FTWR's only appeal was its rarity, just like UK-T and FTN. You missed nothing.

    What.cd was like RED, but with less autosnatch spam. Surprised you weren't a member, invites were easy to find and I had five active accounts at one point

    U-G was the ScT of its niche, and as was discussed above, doesn't really have a successor. Also surprised you weren't in, they regularly had open signups.

    STB was perhaps ahead of its time. The target audience just wasn't there - phones were fairly underpowered, compatibility was shaky, and overall they didn't have much to offer other than some packs buried in a mass of <1 MB torrents.

    It would be interesting to see what ScT and STB would look like if they were still active today, given the boom in P2P releases and mobile apps that took place not so long after their death.
    "I just remembered something that happened a long time ago."
    Reply With QuoteReply With Quote
    Thanks

+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may post new threads
  • You may post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •