Printable View
Hi @all.
I would put this question here on SBI because a lot of people download a lot of thing.
Guys, how you know wich Rip have better quality ? (Of course with same tag, for example between 3 DVDRip or 3 BRRip...)
You need to download it, and see for example 1 AVINaptic report, or ?
:top:
technically BDRip should be the best. however in the end it depends on what settings have been used
Yes, BDRip (or BRRip, is the same thing), is better, but between for example 4 Rips, from 4 different crew, I would some advice for understand who is the best! (Of course the difference is minimal)
oh no, it's not!Quote:
Originally Posted by IlSoldato
Blu-Ray BRRip & BDRip - Two New XviD Formats | THE source for BitTorrent & P2P Tips, Tricks and Info. | FileShareFreak
in the end there is no definitive method to know. in doubt grab the sample and see for yourself but as i said i would try the BDRip first if there's one availableQuote:
between for example 4 Rips, from 4 different crew, I would some advice for understand who is the best! (Of course the difference is minimal)
I always thinked BDRip / BRRip is the same thing in fact in Italy X crew use bd, and Y crew BR but with the same file size!
again, it's not. just read the linkQuote:
Originally Posted by IlSoldato
i never ever check the samples (if included) nor do i download multiple ripped versions of the same movie - the rule of the thumb for me is simple: if its released by a scene group and it hasn't been nuked, then its most likely a very good rip, meaning there is no need to search for a better one, period - if there are multiple scene versions available i'll either go for a more respectable group (fi. diamond over movierush) or for a more convenient way of downloading (fi. private tracker vs. multiple och download links) - any other source (non-scene) is a last-resort option as far as i'm concernedQuote:
Guys, how you know wich Rip have better quality ? (Of course with same tag, for example between 3 DVDRip or 3 BRRip...)
You need to download it, and see for example 1 AVINaptic report, or ?
in case of bluray rips scene releases don't score well. in terms of quality p2p groups win most of the timeQuote:
Originally Posted by slikrapid
I have a simple rule for that sort of stuff - "if the name is different, it's not the same". Of course that's not always right, but it works for me. :wgrin:Quote:
Originally Posted by Instab
Regarding the actual topic, any semi-decent tracker or download site should provide a sample or caps, precisely so that you can check the quality before downloading.
'been there, done that' :P :Quote:
Originally Posted by Instab
Quote:
Originally Posted by myself
sure, depends on how picky you areQuote:
Originally Posted by slikrapid
ITS have some BDRip high quality
BRRip - they usualy use scene releases x264 moust them do not know encode also moust p2p rips are oversharpened [ i am talking about some TL teams ]
BDRip - this is the best option they use the original bluray [~ 40 gb] this will be a accredited and quality team
if you want I can give the name some excelent teams and some ed2k forums where there's high quality BDRip´s [ just send me pm ]
he is asking how to choose between 3 different BDRips (for that matter) of the same movie.
ok let's take "The Book Of Eli" as an example.
in TL we have a few 720p XviD rips.
The Book of Eli 2010 720p BRRip XviD AC3-FLAWL3SS
The Book Of Eli 2010 720p BRRip AC3 XviD-SHiRK
The Book Of Eli 2010 720p BRRip XviD AC3-ViSiON
and of course the BDRip, which is encoded directly from a bluray disc (as opposed to a BRRip which is ripped from a MKV file rip of a bluray disc = 2 reencodes) and thus provides the superior quality.
between these 3 there is NO WAY of telling which provides the best visual quality using only the dry data of size and bitrate, because each group uses different settings and applies different filters.
one rip can be 500 MB bigger than the other (and thus provide higher bit rate) but the other will be sharper because of the filters used in the encoding process.
MediaInfo will only tell you the numbers. the bitrate. not the real visual difference that your EYES see.
one way of telling is comparing screenshots, the other way is grabbing the samples which is almost always included, and compare which YOU think looks better.
I, personally, always choose the ViSiON rips because I've learned (after too many comparisons :P) that they are the best.
so what you should do is: choose BDRip. if only BRRips are available, you will choose the ViSiON one. if no ViSiON rip available, you will have to compare screenshots OR samples to really know which is better.
don't go by the scene in the XVID BDRips\BRRips and DVDRips anymore. the scene rules suggest low resolution and prefer low size over quality.
if you care about the quality and not about the size, choose the non scene releases and be wise. search for the best!
I have another suggestion: go 720p first as there various size BDRips this should at least be in the highest quality class. Than just close your eyes and pick one :wtongue:
Secondly try and read a few user comments, if you're on a private tracker as there are quite a few users everywhere that give competent feedback on the release.